A Benchmark Change: Replacing the Wilshire 5000

Apr 28, 2026
Listen to Article:

More than 30 years ago, Austin chose the Wilshire 5000 Index as SMI’s primary measure of U.S. stock market performance because it was the broadest measure of the market. Unlike other indexes that measure a specific market segment or use a representative sample of stocks, the Wilshire 5000 captured nearly every publicly traded U.S. stock. Eventually, however, other indexes (such as the S&P 500) eclipsed the Wilshire 5000, pushing it toward irrelevance. Recently, Wilshire sold the rights to this index, and the data is no longer available to us.

Fortunately, in the 1990s Vanguard made the Wilshire 5000 the benchmark for its Total Stock Market Index Fund (VSTSX). Even though Vanguard later shifted to a different, similar index (CRSP US Total Market), VSTSX’s performance record has been virtually identical to the Wilshire 5000 data series. As such, SMI will use VSTSX’s monthly returns as our benchmark for “U.S. Market” performance going forward. 

Written by

Mark Biller

Mark Biller

Mark joined SMI in 2000. He leads the SMI newsletter’s overall content strategy, managing the editorial direction and writing many articles.

He helped develop several of SMI’s investment strategies, led the company’s efforts to create its first website, and has been a contributing author to The Sound Mind Investing Handbook.

Mark also serves as Senior Portfolio Manager to SMI Advisory Service’s Private Client managed-account program, the SMI Funds, and the SMI 3Fourteen Full-Cycle Trend ETF (FCTE) and REAL Asset Allocation (RAA) ETF's.

Follow Mark on X/Twitter at @mark_biller.

Guiding Investors With Wisdom, Clarity, and Peace of Mind Since 1990

Black Friday Sale — Save 35% on SMI Premium + FREE SMI Handbook!


For over 35 years, Sound Mind Investing has guided more than 70,000 Christians to invest with confidence and clarity — combining biblical wisdom with time-tested strategies for every market condition. The result? Peace of mind for the future, freedom to live generously, and a clear plan to steward God’s resources wisely.

Now it’s your turn — this Black Friday, join today and save 35% on SMI Premium and get a free SMI Handbook. This offer ends November 27!

Join today and save! (New Subscribers Only)